Is a Social Credit score System Coming for Us?

Is a Social Credit System Coming for Us?


A Social Credit score Rating System Is Piloted in Bologna, Italy

The town administration of Bologna, Italy, is piloting a program that brings the beast of the Fourth Industrial Revolution straight to the residents. It is an early reiteration of Klaus’ Schwab’s Fourth Industrial Revolution, the honey moon, so to talk — so it involves the residents wrapped in reward paper, with balloons, prizes, and get together language. However make no mistake: beneath, there’s merciless man-eating machine that wishes to mine your knowledge and management your conduct!

So, what precisely is occurring in Bologna? The administration is “digitizing” their relationship with the residents. For starters, they’re launching an app — with a catch — that can present an interface to get entry to varied native companies. With out saying it, the they’re implementing the “digital governance” facet of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Quoting the Italian supply:

“We’ll give residents companies primarily based on their wants – says the Mayor – and this may enable us to personalize their expertise. Folks will be capable to discover every little thing the administration will do on their cellphones or computer systems. The bodily branches, nevertheless, won’t disappear.

“We’ll preserve a ‘bodily’ help for all individuals who don’t use the net, particularly the older ones,” assures Lepore [Mayor of Bologna]. However the aim is pc literacy that leaves nobody behind.”

If we learn this announcement with harmless eyes, it appears like one more initiative that the bureaucrats are launching, maybe benevolently, to maintain up with the occasions and with the buzzwords. And in a super world — a world stuffed with flowers, butterflies, rainbows, and innocent, caring bureaucrats — there can be nothing mistaken with including on slightly further comfort by way of expertise.

Know-how might be very useful if executed proper, and if it involves us with out Trojan horses. However alas, in the mean time, we do not stay in such a world!

We stay in a world the place Klaus Schwab and his buddies and masters are combating with one another over who will get to eat essentially the most peasants! We stay in a world the place those that have already got nice energy are looking for much more energy — and that world is shortly going again to the feudal-time psychological requirements (whereas, sarcastically, holding the fashionable requirements for the degrees of business poisons in every little thing round us.)

So far as Trojan horses, the Bologna municipal app really comes with a social credit score system! The “virtuous residents,” doing good issues, reminiscent of utilizing public transport, holding their power use low, and many others., get “perks,” like factors in gaming. For these factors, they can get reductions or prizes or entry to extra companies. Good Computer virus, proper?

“Among the many most progressive interventions is the good citizen pockets [emphasis mine]. ‘The pockets of the virtuous citizen,’ explains Bugani, who had labored on the undertaking with the Raggi [Virginia Raggi, Mayor of Rome from 2016 to 2021] administration (in Rome at present the platform is lively in an experimental part). The thought is just like the mechanism of ‘a grocery store factors assortment,’ because the councilor himself factors out.

‘Residents shall be acknowledged in the event that they separate waste, in the event that they use public transport, in the event that they handle power properly, if they don’t incur sanctions from the municipal authority, if they’re lively with the Tradition Card.’ Virtuous behaviors that can correspond to a rating that the Bolognese will then be capable to ‘spend’ on prizes, reminiscent of reductions, cultural actions and so forth.”

In different phrases, it is the “good” face of digital management. Good, for now. However we have to be clear: we’re trying on the digital management of every little thing we do in the long run of that journey!

Built-in Citizen Relationship Administration in Rome

The Italian information supply mentions that this strategy is already in experimental use in Rome, Italy. In March 2022, Salesforce revealed the next announcement:

“Salesforce, the worldwide chief in CRM, at present introduced that the Municipality of Rome has chosen Salesforce to create an Built-in Citizen Relationship Administration platform …

Leveraging Salesforce Service Cloud and Advertising and marketing Cloud will ship omni-channel self-service capabilities, seamless collaboration between native authorities departments, and empower residents to obtain the data they want quicker via AI-powered chatbots.

The launch of the MyRhome platform is one other step on the Municipality’s path to making a ‘good metropolis’ [emphasis mine] — an ecosystem of private and non-private stakeholders serving residents wherever they’re”.

In fact! We will not count on any much less from Salesforce, provided that Marc Benioff is on WEF Board of Trustees!

Additionally, keep in mind the well-known “lockstep situation” doc launched by the Rockefeller Basis and the World Enterprise Community? The doc that the Rockefeller Basis says at present has been misinterpreted by the conspiracy theorists — as a result of the nice and virtuous Rockefeller Basis completely did not imply to foretell what really occurred in 2020 (and in addition in all probability had nothing to do with eugenics)?

Nicely, holding in thoughts that “lockstep situation” doc, right here is Peter Schwartz, the Senior Vice President of Strategic Planning at Salesforce and “an internationally famend futurist and enterprise strategist, specializing in situation planning and dealing with firms, governments, and establishments to create different views of the long run …

Previous to becoming a member of Salesforce, Peter was co-founder and chairman of World Enterprise Community [emphasis mine].” Within the phrases of George Carlin, “It is a large membership, and also you ain’t in it! You and I usually are not within the large membership!”

Their Motive for the “Digital Governance” Mannequin? It is the Information, Silly!

At first, it is the info (to coach our future boss, the robotic) — after which, more and more, it is primarily about management!

Let us take a look at a really “attention-grabbing” 2017 write-up on digitizing governments on the World Financial Discussion board’s web site. It talks in regards to the significance of accumulating knowledge to construct and practice their beloved AI. It additionally complains about the truth that a variety of the info saved by governments simply sits there in paper format and, dammit, just isn’t making itself helpful to the sacred aim of coaching the AI! Not good, they are saying, what a waste!

Due to this fact, to “open” that knowledge to the AI beast, they need the governments to digitize their companies — sorry that was the quiet half — what they really say is that the residents are craving these digital authorities techniques as a result of, who would not know that the elimination of privateness is … good for us?

The World Financial Discussion board additionally means that the governments ought to develop new authorized frameworks and knowledge administration techniques to make knowledge out there totally free. What an amazing concept! In 2017, the World Financial Discussion board mouthpieces had been extra upfront that at present, so it’s helpful to learn precisely what they stated again then:

“Want for knowledge is shortly turning into a central theme that applies to all points of our evolving digital society. A living proof is the sector of synthetic intelligence, which guarantees to revolutionize society (governments included). Firms reminiscent of Google, Fb and Microsoft are utilizing AI-related methods to coach computer systems to acknowledge objects in pictures and perceive human language.

It’s doable to coach computer systems to carry out these tough feats as a result of we’ve the big portions of information that’s required. The identical applies to all types of machine studying, good manufacturing and each different tech-driven pattern shaping the long run. They’re all reliant on knowledge, and are solely nearly as good as the info they crunch. On this context, knowledge has been described as the brand new oil.'”

“Right this moment, a big majority of the world’s knowledge is within the fingers of the non-public sector … The rest of the worldwide knowledge sits in authorities fingers, largely saved in paper format, or legacy techniques. To maximise the societal advantages of the info age, a brand new motion began selling open knowledge.

Whereas authorities knowledge is all knowledge or info that authorities entities produce or acquire, making it open refers to publishing and sharing knowledge that may be readily and simply consulted and re-used by anybody with entry to web with no charges or technological boundaries.

Most of this knowledge at the moment stays locked up and proprietary (non-public property of firms, governments and different organizations). This severely limits its public worth.

Information is now a brand new social good and governments might want to consider some type of knowledge accountability laws that guides the non-public sector and different knowledge house owners on their duties within the knowledge age: the obligation to gather, handle and share in a well timed method [emphasis mine], in addition to the obligation to guard.

This laws is required over and above a authorities’s personal open and large knowledge administration techniques, and might want to cowl all knowledge stakeholders (no matter possession or different governing guidelines).”

“As soon as a transparent authorized framework is in place, governments must develop, and shortly grasp, a brand new core functionality: knowledge curation … Most governments all over the world nonetheless wrestle with legacy databases which can be incompatible with one another, and work in opposition to any sort of data-sharing or data-driven design. Legal guidelines and rules are nonetheless of their infancy and struggling to deal with the tempo of change …”

“Governments should evaluate an unlimited variety of legal guidelines and rules [emphasis mine]. From harmonizing and imposing privateness rules and defending in opposition to data-breaches, to rules that guarantee web neutrality and knowledge flows. Right this moment’s debates over the way forward for large knowledge are primarily based on the belief that the web will stay a sequence of open networks via which knowledge simply flows.

Some international locations have begun to harden their web techniques, and the idea of web neutrality is unsure. If the web turns into a community of closed networks, the total potential of massive knowledge is probably not realized.”

“Governments should additionally enhance their capabilities on the subject of citizen engagement to successfully and actively have interaction with each suppliers and customers of information. This requires governments to create a tradition of open knowledge [emphasis mine] – one thing governments are beginning to do with varied levels of success.

The extent of citizen engagement just isn’t the everyday authorities communication perform, however a extra open, horizontal, and fast-paced G2C platform.”

Should, should, should. So I’m guessing, nationwide sovereignty is a sore thumb in the best way of our aspiring Davos masters as a result of of their minds, they’ve already determined that they need our knowledge (however not theirs) to be overtly out there, and that they do not need any questions from the peasants.

A tangential remark: As a musician, I’m remembering with some bitterness how Massive Tech was pushing for “open knowledge” and “open entry” again within the day, promoting it as “free expression” and “democracy,” and consequently — since shopping for music grew to become retro — musicians misplaced a lot of their revenue … and no one cared!

I’m glad that now a minimum of, much more individuals are realizing what liars whose Massive Tech firms are, and what liars they’ve at all times been all alongside, once they had been speaking about “free expression”! Have a look at them now, with their “free expression”! They’re fairly blissful to censor! So it is solely our knowledge that they wish to be open — not our opinions!

And Right here Is One other Curiosity From the World Financial Discussion board

They revealed this text in 2018:


“The Fourth Industrial Revolution is predicted to wreak havoc on labour markets, with AI and robots changing varied white-collar jobs. One job class largely excluded from scientific experiences is that of presidency leaders, regardless of being one of the crucial critiqued, scrutinized and ridiculed jobs of all.”

“Nevertheless, commentators from international locations as various as India, the UK, New Zealand and Japan have began to counsel that robots as authorities leaders might drastically enhance decision-making, by being a lot much less irrational and erratic than their inherently flawed human counterparts.”

After freaking us out, the World Financial Discussion board writers chuckle and allow us to proceed being ruled by human politicians, a minimum of for now:

“In the meanwhile, it appears neither doable nor optimum for robots to switch authorities leaders, regardless of the clear imperfections displayed by the latter group … In the end, a extra reasonable and fascinating situation is one wherein AI and automation are neither opponents nor substitutes to people, however instruments that authorities leaders can have interaction successfully and generally defer to, in an effort to make higher, fairer and extra inclusive choices.”

Phew, it is nearly like … , when a avenue robber first tells us to present him your whole cash however then agrees to take solely half! Such a kindly, beneficiant robber! We’re so fortunate!

World Financial Discussion board’s “Agile Nations”

The 2017 WEB write-up about digital governance reads like a “want checklist” and a blueprint for the governments to behave upon. (I assume, given the bribing and coercive energy of the individuals who’ve composed the want checklist, their want checklist had a powerful likelihood of turning into the bureaucrats’ blueprint the second it was written.) So in 2020, seven nations obtained collectively and signed an settlement to primarily implement it. A quote from “Agile Canada”:

“In November 2020, seven international locations signed on to the Agile Nations Constitution, establishing Agile Nations as a discussion board for international locations to collaborate on creating a worldwide regulatory atmosphere wherein innovation can thrive.

Member international locations embrace: Canada, Denmark, Italy, Japan, Singapore, the United Arab Emirates, the UK. The Organisation for Financial Cooperation and Improvement (OECD) and the World Financial Discussion board (WEF) additionally take part as observers.”

“Precedence areas for cooperation are: knowledge and communications, transportation, medical analysis and remedy, clear expertise, authorized {and professional} companies, pro-innovation regulatory approaches.”

And here is from the Organisation for Financial Co-operation and Improvement:

“The COVID-19 pandemic has wrought financial and social disruption worldwide. As individuals and companies concentrate on restoration, governments should be sure that innovation, which can energy financial progress and clear up the world’s most urgent social and environmental challenges, just isn’t held again by outdated rules [emphasis mine].”

Translation from Orwellian to English: “We wish your knowledge, together with your medical and biometric knowledge — and we would like it now. Have a look at how pretty our AI is … my valuable! (Sorry could not assist it!) The so referred to as nationwide legal guidelines and rules intrude with the pace at which we are able to come up with your knowledge.

Like we stated, we would like it now, and so we’d very very like it so referred to as nationwide legal guidelines and regulation obtained changed with a digital framework that we write and that we are able to replace any time we like! Feels like a good suggestion or what? Who desires some funding? what it is advisable do to get that funding, do not you?” The quote continues:

“As a part of the event of the OECD rules on Efficient and Innovation Pleasant Rule-Making within the Fourth Industrial Revolution, the Organisation for Financial Cooperation and Improvement (OECD) and the World Financial Discussion board (WEF) have been co-operating to look deeper into the interlinkages between regulation and rising applied sciences …

Ministers from Canada, Denmark, Italy, Japan, Singapore, United Arab Emirates and United Kingdom introduced their plan to steer the world in fostering accountable innovation and entrepreneurship.”

“As well as, in help of the mission of the Agile Nations, representatives of Fb additionally supplied to launch a name for analysis – overseen by an unbiased steering committee of consultants within the subject of regulation, regulation and entrepreneurship – into what approaches to rulemaking (e.g. regulatory sandboxes, coverage prototyping) had been the simplest for the Fourth Industrial Revolution.

As this initiative continues to develop, different companies shall be inspired and invited to co-sponsor this initiative, and to enterprise their very own concepts to help the work of the Agile Nations.”

“In sum, the Agile Nations Constitution units out every nation’s dedication to making a regulatory atmosphere wherein new concepts can thrive. The settlement paves the best way for these nations to cooperate in serving to innovators navigate every nation’s guidelines, check new concepts with regulators and scale them throughout the seven markets.

Precedence areas for cooperation embrace the inexperienced economic system, mobility, knowledge, monetary {and professional} companies, and medical analysis and remedy.”

“Scientific Administration”

The World Financial Discussion board’s agenda is an odd combine of non secular fundamentalism and “scientific administration.” As I wrote earlier in an article in regards to the thoughts of a technocrat, scientific administration is a “methodology of business optimization developed by Taylor within the late 19th and early 20th century. The essence of his methodology was excessive fragmentation and compartmentalization of the manufacturing course of.”

It required taking a fancy course of, breaking it down into quite simple duties, timing every job, optimizing it to the utmost utilizing the stopwatch, after which assigning every of these easy duties to totally different staff, whereas insisting that the employees ought to solely use the pre-optimized motor patterns and work as effectively as doable. Below scientific administration, there was no room for staff’ creativity.

And whereas Taylor and Ford meant the scientific administration methodology for the aim of streamlining industrial manufacturing, the Davos charlatans intention to handle our total lives, and justify it with some bogus “public good” and “group values”!

Whose “Neighborhood Values” Are These, Anyway?

Right here is the elephant within the room: It is the Davos charlatans — and I wish to repeat the phrase “charlatans” as a result of that is who they’re beneath their financial institution accounts and their necessary speeches — who’re writing our so referred to as “group values”! They’re making an attempt to latch onto our pure social instincts and weaponize our good instincts in opposition to us!

They need us to be unassuming, responsible “good residents” who put a restrict on our carbon footprint and on the variety of kids we’ve — whereas they, the self-appointed “guardians” of the world, fly non-public jets to local weather change conferences and have as many children as they rattling like!

And here is the factor. There may be nothing mistaken with actual group values! We’re social creatures, and it advantages us to stay collectively properly. Nevertheless, group values are solely nearly as good because the individuals who suggest them — and group values flip right into a pumpkin the second somebody like Schwab touches them!

As Good because the Folks

Let’s even overlook about Schwab for a second and assume how group values work in precept. We could say a small village. If the individuals residing in that village are largely healed and grounded, they may increase their kids to hunt knowledge and stay properly with others — from the guts, not from the letter.

Nevertheless, if the individuals within the village have been abused, and abused, and abused once more — and by no means healed — then even the genuine group values in that village might find yourself being anxious, inflexible, and detrimental to freedom.

Harm individuals have a tendency to show their kids that life is supposed to be joyless. They have an inclination to slap their kids’s wrists for eager to be free, saying it is a egocentric folly. Harm individuals harm individuals! And at one level, the inflexible guidelines may need been an invention of a crafty predator — however after extended abuse, individuals may need internalized them and handed them on to their kids! (And have a look at how many individuals within the West sincerely adopted the faith of the Masks … they’ve internalized it!)

One other instance: in my beginning homeland of Russia, they’re many small communities the place the individuals carry a lot harm and unhappiness that the gloom is nearly palpable within the air. I’m saying this from private expertise, and with a lot ache and love for my individuals. I ran away from that gloom and immigrated to America as a result of the “group values” felt too joyless!

So on the subject of Klaus Schwab and buddies, they’re solely as highly effective as we allow them to. I consider that that therapeutic ourselves and {our relationships} is on the high of our priorities checklist within the battle in opposition to transhumanism — as a result of something we do from a spot of affection has extra energy than something we do from the place of worry!

Why Will Transhumanism Fail?

This method, the complete man-eating beast, will finally fail, I’ve little doubt — however we do not know when, and we have to keep humble, courageous, and really affected person. The merciless beast might fail very quickly, or it might take some time to fail. I feel it is determined by how shortly we keep in mind to narrate to one another in spirit, with love and blissful humility — as a substitute of labeling and judging one another primarily based on ancestry, politics, or variations in opinion.

I feel it is determined by how shortly we understand that the liberty taken away from the individuals in every single place, all through historical past, has been as existentially valuable as the liberty that’s being taken away from us proper now — as a result of there isn’t a elementary distinction between us and different individuals, and by no means has been.

We, right here and now, are coping with the identical dilemma that many prior to now have handled, and a few have died from. Spirit is spirit, and freedom is freedom! And I feel that after we keep in mind to face collectively and honor one another and one another’s love and one another’s braveness, we’ll be undefeatable. No Klaus Schwab can do something to us if we refuse to betray our fellow human beings for any motive.

And in the end, non secular readability will prevail, and this transhumanist beast, the fruits of abuse, will fail. The explanation why it would fail is straightforward. We’re not machines, and after we are managed like machines — more and more so over the centuries — our souls bleed badly. Once we are managed like slaves, we undergo unbearably — and struggling, whereas it is not a most well-liked means of acquiring readability, nonetheless mysteriously results in non secular readability. Life places no struggling to waste!

And when the ache will get insufferable, and there’s nowhere to go however towards our coronary heart of hearts, our souls scream to the skies, and we pray for solutions with no vanity and no speaking factors, after which one thing magical occurs. When our worry and ache turn out to be an excessive amount of however we hold pushing, we develop our souls to the place options present up out of nowhere.

After which we cry, snicker, and pray extra for therapeutic, and extra options present up, and we glance again and we all of a sudden know why we needed to undergo, and why the sweetness was price it. After which we begin residing properly as a result of, in any case this struggling, we lastly keep in mind that every little thing on the planet, everything-everything, has at all times been about love — and that residing properly with one another is not only nice but additionally very sensible.

Concerning the Creator

To search out extra of Tessa Lena’s work, you’ll want to try her bio, Tessa Fights Robots.